Sports City Pizza Pub Menu
54 items in 7 sections · $2.99 – $85.99 · Pizza Restaurant in Buffalo, NY
Sports City Pizza Pub’s menu lists 54 dishes and drinks, grouped into Appetizers, Dinners, Burgers, Desserts, Pizza, and Wings / Boneless and more. Prices range from $2.99 to $85.99, and a typical item costs about $14.49. Popular choices include 5pc Chicken Finger Dinner (W/FF), Cheeseburger, 5 Apple Logs with Caramel Dipping Sauce, Pizza Logs, and Specialty Crust.
Appetizers 10
- Pizza Logs
5 pc - $6.99 | 10 pc - $12.99
- Potato Skins
5 pc - $8.49 | 10 pc - $15.49 • Cheddar & bacon.
- In The Grass Potato Skins
5 pc - $10.99 | 10 pc - $17.49 • Feat roasted red peppers, mushrooms & spinach.
- Veggie Potato Skins with Broccoli
5 pc - $8.99 | 10 pc - $15.99
- Basket of French Fries$2.99
- Mozzarella Sticks
5 pc - $6.49 | 10 pc - $11.99
- Basket of Onion Rings$5.49
- Basket of Flavored Fries$3.25
Choice of Cajun or Italian.
- Basket of Tots$5.99
- Mac & Cheese Bites$6.49
Dinners 6
- 5pc Chicken Finger Dinner (W/FF)$14.49
Flavors on the Pit +$1.00
- 10pc Chicken Finger Dinner (W/FF)$22.99
Flavors on the Pit +$2.00
- Fresh Fish Fry Dinner (W/FF)$15.99
Available starting March 7th!
- Super Sized Calzones$12.99
Extra A Toppings +$2.99 | Extra B Toppings +$3.49
- Home Made Stuffed Hot Peppers$12.99
- The Delevan$8.99
Two slices of cheese/pepperoni pizza together with a stuffed hot pepper sandwiched between.
Burgers 2
- Cheeseburger$10.99
- Bacon Burger$12.99
Desserts 2
- 5 Apple Logs with Caramel Dipping Sauce$7.50
- New York Style Cheesecake$3.00
Choice of strawberry, raspberry, or caramel topping.
Pizza 22
- Specialty Crust
BBQ, Cajun, Garlic, Honey, Honey BBQ, Honey Sesame, Italian, Onion, Poppy Seed, Red Pepper, Romano, Sesame Seed.
- A Topping
Medium - $2.49 | Large - $2.99 | Sheet - $4.99 • Anchovies, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Broccoli, Cherries, Cherry Peppers, Green Olives, Jalapeño Peppers, Minced Garlic, Onions, Pineapple, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Sweet Peppers, Sau
- B Topping
Medium - $2.99 | Large - $3.49 | Sheet - $5.99 • Artichoke, Cheddar, Chicken Finger, Fontinella, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Margherita Pepperoni, Smokehouse Bacon, Stuffed Hot Peppers, Sun-Dried Tomatoes, Steak, Breaded Eggplant, Sliced Mushrooms
- Slice
Cheese - $2.99 | Cheese + ‘A’ Topping - $3.49 | Cheese + ‘B’ Topping - $3.99 • Slices available daily: Cheese/Cheese Pepperoni.
- Cheese Pizza
Medium - $16.99 | Large - $20.49 | Sheet - $36.99
- Steak Deluxe
Medium - $22.99 | Large - $27.49 | Sheet - $46.99 • 100% olive oil & italian seasoning, mushrooms, sirloin steak, sweet or banana peppers, onions, and a blend of 4 cheeses.
- Sports City Steak & Stuffed Hot Pepper
Medium - $21.99 | Large - $26.99 | Sheet - $46.99 • Our signature pizza made with 100% olive oil & italian seasoning, sirloin steak, homemade stuffed hot pepper, topped with mozzarella.
- Steak & Finger
Medium - $23.99 | Large - $29.49 | Sheet - $49.99 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, sirloin steak, tender chicken fingers, topped with 3 cheeses | Add Stuffed Hot Peppers.
- Italian White
Medium - $19.99 | Large - $23.99 | Sheet - $38.49 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, fresh sliced tomatoes and onions, topped with light Fontinella | Add Eggplant.
- Chicken Cheddar Broccoli
Medium - $21.49 | Large - $26.49 | Sheet - $43.99 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, tender chicken fingers and fresh broccoli, topped with mozzarella & cheddar.
- Sicilian
Medium - $19.99 | Large - $25.49 | Sheet - $41.99 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, dipped whole tomatoes, banana or sweet peppers, topped with light Fontinella | Choice of steak, chicken finger, or sausage.
- Spinach Ricotta
Medium - $19.99 | Large - $24.99 | Sheet - $40.49 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, spinach, ricotta, onion, topped with mozzarella | Choice of sausage.
- The “Dave Portnoy” New York Style
20”- $24.49 • Extra a Topping +$2.99 | Extra B Topping +$3.49 • Named after Dave Portnoy of “Barstool Sports” - recognizing everything he did for small businesses during the COVID Pandemic • Extra thin dough, signature sauce, topped with mo
- The California
Medium - $21.49 | Large - $25.99 | Sheet - $42.99 • Signature sauce, mushrooms, black & green olives, hot & sweet peppers, onions, topped with mozzarella | Add Pepperoni and/or Sausage.
- Hawaiian
Medium - $20.49 | Large - $23.99 | Sheet $39.99 • Our signature sauce, mozzarella, topped with pepperoni, pineapple, and cherries.
- Buffalo Chicken
Medium - $21.99 | Large - $25.99 | Sheet - $42.99 • Delicious tender chicken fingers mixed to your liking, bleu cheese, and mozzarella | Choice of hot, medium, or mild.
- Southern BBQ Chicken
Medium - $22.49 | Large - $26.49 | Sheet - $43.99 • BBQ base, tender BBQ chicken finger, mozzarella & cheddar, topped with smokehouse bacon | Add Pineapple.
- Supreme Italian
Medium - $21.99 | Large - $24.99 | Sheet - $42.99 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, sliced mushrooms, whole sliced tomato, seasoned spinach, roasted red peppers, artichoke, topped with Fontinella & mozzarella cheese.
- In The Grass
Medium - $21.99 | Large - $25.99 | Sheet - $42.99 • 100% olive oil & Italian seasoning, spinach, roasted red peppers, topped with Fontinella and mozzarella | Choice of chicken finger, steak, or sausage.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch
Medium - $21.99 | Large - $25.99 | Sheet - $42.99 • Authentic ranch base, flavored chicken tenders, topped with mozzarella cheese, & smoke house bacon.
- Nashville Hot Chicken
Medium - $20.99 | Large - $24.99 | Sheet - $41.99 • White authentic base, sprinkled with Dan O’s Seasoning, mixed hot breaded chicken, sliced pickles, coated in a topping of mozzarella & cheddar cheese.
- Breakfast Pizza
Medium - $20.49 | Large - $23.49 | Sheet - $40.99 • Scrambled egg base, mozzarella & cheddar cheese | Add Bacon or Sausage • Weekend Availability.
Wings / Boneless 7
- Flavors
Hot, Medium, Mild, Naked.
- Flavors on The Pit
Add +$1.00/each: BBQ, Chiavetta’s, Roasted Garlic Parm, Honey, Honey BBQ, Honey Mustard, Honey Sesame, Hot, Hot BBQ, Italian, Louisiana Cajun, Hot Cajun, Memphis Style, Medium, Mild, Suicide, Sriracha Garlic, Hot Chipotle, Hot Garlic Parm,
- Extras
Homemade Bleu Cheese +$1.25 | Ranch +$1.00 | Sauce +$1.00
- Single$16.99
10 Wings or 10 Boneless Wings (1 bleu cheese).
- Double$27.99
20 Wings or 20 Boneless Wings (2 bleu cheese).
- Triple$39.99
30 Wings or 30 Boneless Wings (3 bleu cheese).
- Bucket$61.99
50 Wings or 50 Boneless Wings (4 bleu cheese).
Bargains 5
- #1$30.99
Medium Cheese (w/ 1 ‘A’ or ‘B’ topping) and Single Wings (1 bleu cheese).
- #2$44.99
Large Cheese (w/ 1 ‘A’ or ‘B’ topping) and Double Wings (2 bleu cheese).
- #3$53.99
Large Cheese (w/ 1 ‘A’ or ‘B’ topping) and Triple Wings (3 bleu cheese).
- #4$72.49
Large Cheese (w/ 1 ‘A’ or ‘B’ topping) and Bucket Wings (4 bleu cheese).
- #5$85.99
Sheet Cheese (w/ 1 ‘A’ or ‘B’ topping) and 50 Wings (4 bleu cheese).
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.